Published in the September 2016 issue of National Geographic Traveller (UK)
Whether it’s fiery ‘goat water’, lobster with hot pepper sauce, curried yam or Killer Bee rum cocktails, Nevis offers the simple pleasures and a taste of the Caribbean with a serious kick
One handwritten sign says ‘Hot soup sells here’ while another offers up ‘Live rabbits, ducks, local drinks, noni (fruit) juice’. I’m drawn not so much by today’s bull foot broth, but by the bright aqua colours of the shack and the smile of a little boy I later learn goes by the name of J’Kingley. This is the roadside shop, pop-up cafe and petting zoo of the Liburd family, a joyous ramshackle place at the edge of the New River Estate on the Caribbean island of Nevis. My guava juice is not only cold and sweet, but freshly squeezed and delightfully cheap.
Once a sugar plantation, the New River Estate presides on the south east of this little island measuring just six by eight miles. Most of the stone edifices of the mills and boiling and curing houses that dominated the place during the slave trade remain; in 1655 sugar was the most important export crop from Nevis, the oldest British colony in the Caribbean. Some of these old plantations lie in decay, while others have been converted into hotels, residences and restaurants. In spite of the blood and toil upon which they were built, they’re still stoically beautiful.
It’s at the foot of one such mill in the Maddens area that I meet up with Alfred ‘Baba’ Tyson, a former police officer who leads nature tours of the verdant island. As we walk through the rainforest, he stops to pick up various herbs, squashes them in his hand to release the scent and asks me to guess what it is. I can’t and he tells me this one with the spicy overtones may smell like curry leaves but is actually mint basil.
“We boil and make tea with it when we have a cold,” he says.
As we wander, Baba points to a tamarind tree with a monkey trap underneath and tells me how the vervet monkey population has become a nuisance since the animals came down from Mount Nevis after Hurricane Hugo in 1989.
“The vegetation around the tops of Mount Nevis was destroyed to such an extent that the monkey thought, ‘Me not got nothing to eat, me going down to the lowlands’. They discovered all the melons and all the ting the farmer grow and they stay put.” He points out a cashew tree from which no human ever gets nuts because the monkeys always get them first. No wonder, then, that some locals take great delight in eating monkey.
“If you see ‘tree mutton’ in the supermarket, it’s monkey,” Baba warns.
I leave Baba and hook up with Patterson Fleming, the maitre d’ at Nisbet Plantation, my hotel, who has a nice sideline offering guided tours of the rum shacks dotted all over the island. We meet convivial Esme, owner of Esme’s Sunrise Snackette and chat over a Mount Gay rum and Ting (popular fizzy grapefruit drink). At another bar we bump into King Dis and Dat, a calypso champion (real name Keith Scarborough MBE) who smiles as he devours his plate of chicken soup.
In Rawlins Village, in an area known as ‘the breadbasket of Nevis’ because of its abundance of fruit and fresh produce, I visit the industrial kitchen of British-born Llewellyn Clarke, who makes Nevis gourmet hot sauces in the basement of his in-law’s house. He shows me vast tubs of the bright red and orange fiery Scotch bonnet peppers collected and sold to him by church groups across the island. A Manchester lad, Clarke moved to Nevis to look after his elderly father and, while working as a chef, began making sauces, jams, chutneys, ice cream and sorrel wine, a kind of red liqueur traditionally drunk in the Caribbean at Christmas.
“I started making pepper sauce in 2003 and sold it to shops, then supermarkets, and it became huge, mostly through word of mouth. My Nevis hot pepper sauce has a sweetness and depth because I add thyme. It’s got flavour and character,” he says. “A lot of the time West Indian pepper sauce is just hot. Mine is different.”
At Sunshine’s, on Pinney’s Beach, the tables have bottles of Llewellyn’s hot and mango sauce and I try both with fresh lobster. The seafood flesh is soft and has a buttery flavour, perfectly matched to the hot sauce.
The restaurant is famed for its Killer Bee, a rum cocktail invented by owner Llewellyn Caines, known to all as Sunshine. “My grandmother called me Sunshine from the day I was born because I smiled and didn’t stop,” he says. “I can’t tell you the secret of my Killer Bee, but it’s so good people come over from St Kitts just to drink it.”
The drink is sweet and a little spicy and I resolve that more than two would most definitely be a killer, so I err on the side of caution. Later, down at the beachfront restaurant chef Elsa teaches me the secrets of a good goat curry — it’s in the subtlety of the spices — and tells me that ‘goat water’, a Nevisian dish, is, in fact, more like a cross between a soup and a stew and is, in spite of its name, often not watery at all.
Later, in the historical dining room up at the old house, I try it. I taste clove, black pepper, thyme and Scotch bonnet in the sauce, and the goat — often referred to as mutton — is tender, paired nicely with chunks of breadfruit. Patterson brings me a Carib beer. And not a moment too soon, as like so many things in Nevis, goat water has a bit of a kick.
Five Nevis food finds
Fried fish & Johnny cakes: Nevis’s national dish of fresh fried fish served with delicious fluffy fried dumplings.
Goat water: A cross between a stew and a soup made from goat meat, fiery spices and breadfruit.
Nevis lobster: The island lobster is sweet and moist. Try it in a sandwich at the Golden Rock Hotel, located at the base of Mount Nevis.
Cookup: A hotch potch one-pot dish of chicken wings, pigtail and snout, rice, celery and spices — served mostly at the weekend.
Llewellyn’s Gourmet Pepper Sauces: Fiery Nevis hot pepper sauce and mango pepper sauce all made by hand on the island.
A taste of Nevis
Perched on a hill in the middle of the Hamilton Estate, this funky restaurant and bar often has live music and is owned by Gillian Smith, a former dancer. Go there for seriously ‘good home cooking’ and to sample fiery goat water served in a traditional coal pot or the ‘taste of Nevis’ platter, with conch fritters, salt fish and Johnny cakes and tannia (a local root vegetable) fritters.
How much: Three-course meal from £12 per person without wine.
The Great House at Nisbet Plantation
Under the swoosh of fans, the fine dining experience at this grand old plantation house — the ancestral home of Fanny Nisbet, wife of Horatio Nelson — takes you back in time. Each day a ‘taste of Nevis’ dish features on the largely international menu — goat water, say, or grilled mahi mahi.
How much: Dinner (three courses) from £21 per person without wine.
Restaurant 750, Montpelier Plantation
Housed on a converted sugar plantation, the restaurant at this boutique hotel has an outdoor terrace with far-reaching views over the island’s capital, Charlestown, and neighbouring St Kitts. Local ingredients lead the menu with starters such as breadfruit vichyssoise, curried yam and tannia hot soup and coconut-crusted shrimp.
How much: Three courses from £12 per person without wine.